alt

The intense strategic and diplomatic pressures mounted on Beijing have prompted Chinese policy-makers and analysts to give serious attention to the dispute by reviewing other countries’ policies and deliberating on China’s appropriate responses and future policy options. This paper attempts to examine the domestic debate in China concerning the South China Sea dispute since 2009. It seeks to provide a comprehensive overview of the Chinese debate on three issues: (1) the ways various schools of thought have viewed the South China Sea dispute, (2) the types of policy proposals made, and (3) areas where consensus and disagreements exist. I will also attempt to analyze how the debate relates to China’s official position and actual policy and  behaviour in the dispute. Being the most powerful party and having engaged in three military conflicts in the territorial dispute, China’s policy is critical in shaping the future developments of the dispute and also the dynamics of regional security. From this comprehensive overview, we can derive some useful clues to better understand China’s response to the South China Sea dispute in the coming years.

Four notable themes seem to have emerged from the Chinese debate. First, contrary to the widespread external criticism of China for its growing assertiveness, the predominant view among Chinese analysts is that all the tensions and disputes are mainly attributable to the collusion between the United States and regional claimant states. Second, it has been frequently proposed that China should be more proactive in the South China Sea in order to change its current reactive posture. It has been suggested that China can achieve this goal by taking initiatives in three areas: accelerating exploitation of resources in the South China Sea; restraining the involvement of the United States  in the South China Sea issue;  and exercising greater  flexibility in adopting multilateralism  to  deal with various  non-traditional security challenges in the South China Sea. Third, the majority of Chinese analysts and officials believe that the disputes in the South China Sea in the past few years have led to the worsening of China’s regional security environment. Fourth, it appears that there is an emerging consensus that Beijing should practice a qualified moderate policy in the South China Sea in the near future.

(countinuing)

 

Read full text of this paper here